FPC: Colorado, Denver Have 'Wizard of Oz' Gun Ban
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

Denver Bans Open Carry, and Colorado Won't Recognize Your Permit

Colorado and Denver each blame the other in November 11 court filings over carry rights. FPC says a California visitor like plaintiff Gene Hoffman has no lawful way to carry in Denver. The city's open carry ban and Colorado's refusal to honor his out-of-state permits form the core of the fight.

Bearing Arms|November 14, 2026|4d ago|5 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Denver's Open Carry Ban Leaves Visitors Without a Lawful Option

Colorado and Denver are pointing fingers at each other, and the Firearms Policy Coalition says the gap between their laws leaves visitors with no lawful way to carry. In November 11 court filings in its challenge to Colorado and Denver carry restrictions, the state says its laws allow open carry. Denver bans open carry outright. FPC member and plaintiff Gene Hoffman, a California resident, holds carry permits from other states. Denver argues those permits authorize him to carry concealed. Colorado will not recognize them for him. FPC calls the combined result a ban that neither government wants to own.

Key Details

The dispute turns on specific facts that both sides have put on the record:

  • November 11: Date of the defendants' filings responding to FPC's challenge.
  • Gene Hoffman: FPC member and plaintiff, a California resident who holds non-Colorado carry permits.
  • Colorado's position: The state argues that its laws permit open carry, without addressing Denver's local prohibition on it.
  • Denver's position: The city argues Hoffman's out-of-state permits authorize concealed carry, even though Colorado does not recognize those permits for a California resident.
  • The city's exception: Denver points to an exception for people holding "valid authorization from the city."
  • Police chief declaration: Denver's police chief stated in a declaration that he would have considered a request from Hoffman for that authorization.
  • Vehicle exception: Denver also cites an exception allowing a handgun to be transported in a vehicle.
  • FPC's response: FPC President Brandon Combs said both governments want the court to ignore what their laws actually do.

Two points stand out. First, Denver's authorization exception depends on a government official's discretion. Hoffman has no right to it. Second, a vehicle transport exception does nothing for someone who wants to carry for self-defense while walking around town. FPC's filings argue that neither exception supplies the carry right the Second Amendment protects. Combs framed the state and city positions as an attempt to hide a gun ban behind their respective laws. The case centers on whether a court will assess the two laws together rather than separately.

Background

The Supreme Court's 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen changed the analysis for public carry cases. The Court struck down New York's discretionary "proper cause" requirement for public carry permits. It held that the Second Amendment protects carrying a handgun outside the home for self-defense. Governments must justify restrictions by pointing to historical analogues, not by appealing to general public-safety interests.

Colorado allows adults to openly carry firearms under state law without a permit, which is why the state points to open carry in its defense. Cities and counties in Colorado may impose their own rules, and Denver has long restricted open carry locally. Colorado's concealed carry permit system does not recognize every out-of-state permit. The state's refusal to honor Hoffman's permits, given his California residency, sits at the center of the dispute.

FPC has pursued this kind of challenge before. Combs pointed to the group's earlier victory against California's ban on carry by nonresident permit holders as proof that fundamental rights do not end at the state line. That precedent gives the group a template for arguing that a visitor's right to carry should not depend on which border he crosses.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

Anyone who travels to Denver with a firearm should understand where the gaps are. Permit holders from states without reciprocity with Colorado face the same problem Hoffman does. A permit from home may not authorize concealed carry in Colorado, and Denver's open carry ban removes the other option. Visitors who rely on a non-resident permit need to check Colorado's current recognition rules and Denver's local ordinances before they arrive. Assuming that a state-level rule covers the entire state is a costly mistake in Denver.

Gun owners in Colorado face a related issue. Local ordinances can override state permissions, so a resident who relies on statewide open carry rules could still run afoul of a city ordinance. The Denver exception for "valid authorization from the city" also means that carry rights in the city depend on an official's willingness to grant permission. That arrangement puts discretion where a right should be.

Watch the court docket in this case. Any ruling on whether the state and city laws must be read together could affect how other jurisdictions structure their carry rules, especially where state law permits something that a local ordinance forbids.

DownRange Analysis

Denver's position is weak under Bruen. The city asks the court to accept a discretionary exception as a substitute for a constitutional right. Bruen does not permit that move. A government cannot satisfy the Second Amendment by promising to consider an individual request. The vehicle exception fails for the same reason, because it does not protect carry for self-defense in daily life.

Colorado's argument is only slightly stronger. Its open carry rule is real, but it means little when a city bans the practice entirely. Colorado's refusal to recognize Hoffman's permits also raises a question the state has not answered: why a visitor's lawful permit from another state should count for less than a Colorado permit.

Gun owners should carry the paperwork and the local knowledge. Check the permit recognition status for your home state before traveling to Colorado. Read Denver's ordinances. Do not rely on a state-level summary. Support FPC and similar litigation groups that bring these cases, because the outcome will decide whether a traveling permit holder gets any real protection in Colorado's largest city.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
coloradodenverconcealed-carryreciprocityopen-carryfirearms-policy-coalitionsecond-amendment-litigation
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK